This is one of the most specific, actionable shifts happening in digital marketing right now, and small business owners who move early have a real shot at dominating a space that hasn’t gotten crowded yet.

What Is Generative Engine Optimization (GEO)?

GEO is the practice of structuring your website content, data, and authority signals so that AI tools like ChatGPT, Google’s Gemini-powered AI Overviews, and Perplexity actually cite your business when answering a user’s question. GEO is an advanced digital marketing discipline focused on optimizing website content to be processed, cited, and recommended by AI-powered search engines and large language models, and unlike traditional SEO, which prioritizes click-through rates, it prioritizes citation frequency and brand authority within synthesized AI responses.

In plain terms: ranking #1 on Google used to be the finish line. Now, if the AI answer never mentions your name, it doesn’t matter how high you rank — if an AI doesn’t name you, your business effectively doesn’t exist to that searcher.

Why This Matters More Than Ever in 2026

The numbers explain the urgency clearly. Independent research has found that organic CTR drops 61% for informational queries when a Google AI Overview appears. On top of that, the overlap between top-10 Google rankings and AI Overview citations has collapsed from 75% in mid-2025 to between 17% and 38% by early 2026, which means ranking well no longer guarantees you’ll be the source an AI actually quotes.

The flip side is encouraging: when you do get cited, that traffic tends to convert better. AI search visitors are 4.4x as valuable as the average traditional organic visitor, and AI referral traffic is 3x as likely to convert as other channels. That’s because a user who reaches a site through an AI answer has usually already had the basic question resolved and is following a citation to verify, go deeper, or act, arriving later in the journey and closer to a decision.

Fewer, higher-intent visitors instead of a flood of casual browsers — that’s a trade most small business owners would happily make.

Why Small Businesses Have an Edge Right Now

Big national brands are still figuring out GEO at scale, which gives local and niche businesses a genuine window of opportunity. Most businesses can start with free tools and see results within 4-8 weeks, with local businesses having a particular advantage since they can dominate geographic-specific queries more easily than national competitors.

Even better, GEO doesn’t require a complete strategy overhaul. If a small business is already doing well with SEO, leaning into schema markup, optimizing their Google Business Profile, creating FAQ pages, encouraging customer reviews, and ensuring name, address, and phone number consistency across their web presence will set them up for GEO success. In other words, the fundamentals you’ve probably already been ignoring or half-finishing are exactly what AI engines reward.

How to Start Optimizing for AI Search (Your First Steps)

1. Audit What AI Already Says About You

Before changing anything, ask ChatGPT, Gemini, and Perplexity questions your customers would ask — “best [your service] in [your city]," or “how much does [your service] cost." See if your business shows up, and if the information is accurate. This is your baseline.

2. Add Structured Data and Clean Up Your NAP

Schema markup helps AI engines understand exactly what you offer, your pricing, hours, and service area. Consistent name, address, and phone number listings across your website, Google Business Profile, and directories remove the ambiguity that keeps AI models from confidently citing you.

• Add Organization and LocalBusiness schema to your homepage
• Add Product or Service schema to key service pages
• Standardize your NAP across every listing and citation source

3. Build FAQ-Style Content Around Real Questions

AI engines favor content that directly answers a specific question in clear, quotable language. AI search models are sophisticated enough to ignore “fluff," so to rank you need expert-level writing that AI models prefer to quote. Rewrite key headers as actual questions your customers ask, and answer them in two to three concise sentences right underneath.

4. Lean Into Original Data and Reviews

Generic advice gets paraphrased and ignored. Original data, case studies, and customer reviews are harder for AI to replicate or skip, giving your content a better shot at being the cited source rather than an anonymous input.

Track the Right Metrics, Not Just Traffic

Don’t panic if your overall organic sessions dip. If rankings remain steady but traffic falls, AI Overviews are absorbing informational searches — raw session counts are the wrong primary metric in 2026. Instead, check Google Search Console’s AI Overviews filter, track leads and conversions rather than pageviews, and monitor how often your brand actually gets mentioned by name in AI tools.

Your Next Move

GEO isn’t a replacement for SEO — it’s the next layer built on top of it. The small businesses that treat this as urgent homework instead of a future trend will be the ones AI engines recommend by name a year from now. Start with one page: pick your most important service page, add clean schema, rewrite the headers as real customer questions, and see what happens. If you’d rather have a team handle the audit, structuring, and citation-building for you, Kicks Digital Marketing can help you build a GEO strategy that actually gets your business named in the answers your customers are already asking for.

The post GEO for Small Business: Get Cited in AI Search Results appeared first on Kicks Digital Marketing.

Server response time, often measured as Time to First Byte (TTFB), is the amount of time it takes your web server to send back the very first piece of data after a visitor’s browser requests your page. Before a single image loads, before any text appears, your server has to wake up, process the request, and start sending information. If that step is slow, everything downstream is slow too — no amount of front-end tweaking can fix it.

Why Server Response Time Is a Hidden SEO Problem

Most small business owners have heard of Core Web Vitals by now, even if the acronyms LCP, INP, and CLS still sound like alphabet soup. What fewer people realize is that hosting quality sits underneath all three metrics. Websites meeting Core Web Vitals thresholds—LCP under 2.5 seconds, INP under 200ms, CLS below 0.1—rank higher because fast performance signals quality to search algorithms.

Largest Contentful Paint (LCP), the metric that measures how quickly your main content appears, can’t even begin its countdown until your server delivers that first byte. That means a slow host puts you behind before the race even starts. Industry data backs this up: shared hosting averages 400–800ms TTFB under normal load, before a single pixel loads, while sites on faster infrastructure average under 150ms. That gap alone can be the difference between passing and failing your LCP benchmark.

The Business Cost, Not Just the Ranking Cost

This isn’t just a technical scorecard issue — it’s a revenue issue. According to Google, 53% of mobile visitors abandon sites taking longer than 3 seconds to load. And the damage compounds: going from a 1-second to a 3-second load time increases bounce probability by 32%, while going from 1 second to 5 seconds increases bounce probability by 90%.

If you run a service business where phone calls and form submissions are your lifeblood, a slow server is directly costing you leads. As many local SEO specialists have pointed out, someone searching for an emergency plumber at night isn’t going to patiently wait for your homepage to load — they’ll simply call the next name on the list. The same logic applies to restaurants, contractors, med spas, and any local business competing for a quick decision.

Why Mobile Makes This Worse

Google evaluates your site primarily through its mobile version, and mobile connections and processors are inherently less forgiving of slow servers. This is a big reason why only about 42% of mobile sites pass all three Core Web Vitals, versus roughly 63% on desktop, even though mobile now accounts for the majority of web traffic and eCommerce sessions. If your hosting is slow on a fast office Wi-Fi connection, it’s likely far worse on a customer’s phone in a parking lot with two bars of signal.

What to Look For (and What to Ask Your Host)

You don’t need to become a server engineer to protect your rankings and your conversions. You just need to ask the right questions when evaluating or auditing your current hosting provider:

• What is your average TTFB? A good host should be able to tell you, or you can measure it yourself with free tools like PageSpeed Insights or GTmetrix.
• Is this shared, managed, or cloud hosting? Shared hosting splits server resources among many unrelated websites — great for cost, risky for consistent speed.
• Do you use a CDN? A content delivery network stores copies of your site closer to your visitors geographically, cutting down transfer time regardless of server location.
• What happens during traffic spikes? If a blog post goes viral or a promotion drives a surge of visitors, does performance degrade?
• Is server-level caching included? Caching at the server level (not just a plugin) reduces the repetitive work your server has to do for each visitor.

Fixing It Doesn’t Have to Break the Budget

The good news is that upgrading hosting is often one of the cheapest, highest-leverage fixes available to a small business. Many specialists note that moving to better hosting typically costs $20 to $50 per month, which pays for itself quickly once you factor in recovered leads and improved rankings. Pairing that upgrade with a free or low-cost CDN, like the tiers offered by major providers, adds another layer of speed without a major investment.

Speed Compounds — So Does Neglect

Here’s the part that catches business owners off guard: hosting-related speed problems don’t stay flat, they tend to get worse over time as your site adds plugins, images, and new pages. Speed optimization is a compounding advantage — sites that maintain excellent Core Web Vitals over time accumulate ranking stability that competitors with variable performance cannot match. That means the business that fixes its hosting today builds a lead that’s genuinely hard for slower competitors to close.

The Bottom Line

Page speed problems are frequently blamed on images, plugins, or bloated themes — and those matter. But if you’ve addressed all of that and your site is still sluggish, your hosting is very likely the bottleneck, and no plugin can fix a server that’s fundamentally too slow to keep up.

At Kicks Digital Marketing, we audit the full picture — hosting, Core Web Vitals, and everything in between — so you’re not guessing where your rankings and conversions are leaking. If your website feels slower than it should, let’s find out why and fix it before it costs you another customer.

The post Slow Hosting Is Quietly Killing Your Google Rankings appeared first on Kicks Digital Marketing.

Just like any relationship, being mutually committed to your project’s success is critical to the agency/client relationship. 

When Anthrotech approached Kicks to update their website we built for them years ago, they brought to the table their full focus and availability. The result was a kick-ass process and finished product.

Back to School with Kicks

The big question: What color is math? Here’s our hot takes from the world’s brightest marketing minds circa 1990-something.

Matt — I always had stylized folders with sitcom characters and stuff. So I guess math is Sophia from Golden Girls.

Josh — Math is green because money. Duh.

Chris — Math is red because trying to do algebra sends me into a blind rage like a bull.

Summer — Math was reddish orange for me! Felt adequately intense for the subject.

Kickin’ It Around Indy

Home Again at Newfields — Ever wanted to scramble around on the roof of a house from the safety of the ground? This new exhibit at the Newfields nature park’s got your back. Free entry, dawn to dusk, all year long.

Indiana State Fair, Aug 2-19 — If you don’t make a beeline for the elephant ear stand, what are you even doing with your life?

S’mores on the Circle, Aug 8 — Snack up and support the Girl Scouts during your lunch break.

One Night of Queen, Aug 9 — Sure, the real Queen may still be touring, but this tribute concert at Clowes Memorial Hall has a Freddie Mercury lookalike. Eat your heart out, Adam Lambert.

The post The Monthly Mullet, August 2024 appeared first on Kicks Digital Marketing.

Lady Liberty isn’t the only one in the spotlight this July. Our pals at American Law Label have a shiny new Kicks-built website that makes their complex offerings super easy to navigate.

Farmers Market-ers

Wake up and smell the small-batch ethically sourced artisanal soap bars. Farmers markets aren’t just for weekends anymore — here’s where you can find the best of the best across town.

The Original Farmers Market
Wednesdays, 10-1:30pm
Monument Circle

SoBro Farmers Market
Wednesdays, 4:30-7:30pm
48th & College

The Statehouse Market
Thursday, 10:30-1:30
Robert D. Orr Plaza

Broad Ripple Farmers Market
Saturdays, 8-noon
Glendale Town Center

Binford Farmers Market
Saturdays, 8-noon
Northview Church

Garfield Park Farmers Market
Saturdays, 9-12:30pm
Garfield Park

Irvington Farmers Market
Sunday, July 14, 1-3pm
Ellenberger Park

Kickin’ It Around Indy

Barbie The Movie: In Concert @ Ruoff, July 14

Indiana Microbrewers Festival, July 20

Limp Bizkit @ Ruoff, July 21

Red Hot Chili Peppers @ Ruoff, July 25

Alanis Morisette + Joan Jett @ Ruoff, July 27

The post The Monthly Mullet, July 2024 appeared first on Kicks Digital Marketing.

9&8 Golf makes some pretty awesome gear that helps you look good and play better on the golf course. Here’s how Kicks teed up some big wins for their new website with ecomm and content marketing.

Oh Yeah… It’s Gamer Time

This June marks three years since the death of the Electronic Entertainment Expo (E3), the world’s biggest video game trade show. Here’s what the Kicks crew is playing while we pour one out in E3’s memory.

Matt — Along with the usuals like PUBG and League of Legends, I’m playing New World and Helldivers 2.

Josh — The only thing I play is mind games and Russian roulette.

Chris — My backlog is bonkers right now. I’ve got Baldur’s Gate 3, The Witcher 3, Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom, Halo Infinite and the new Elden Ring DLC on the bench.

Summer — Well with 4 playthroughs of Baldur’s Gate 3 behind me, I’ve had plenty of time to juggle a new Stardew Valley run and ongoing games in Avatar: Frontiers of Pandora, Destiny 2, Disney Dreamlight Valley, and Kingdom Hearts III.

Kickin’ It Around Indy

Indy Pride Festival, June 8 — The best part of summer in Indy returns. Watch the parade, do some day drinking, and stick around for the afterparty at Military Park.

Juneteenth Foodways Festival, June 14 — Nosh on food from local Black-owned restaurants and entrepreneurs at this 3rd annual celebration at the Benjamin Harrison Presidential Site.

House of the Dragon Season 2, June 16 — The Game of Thrones spinoff is back with more dragons and more back-stabbin’. Rhaenyra, we kneel.

Elden Ring DLC, June 21 — Catch us back in the Lands Between for Shadow of the Erdtree, a massive DLC pack for 2022’s massive hit RPG Elden Ring.

Free RPG Day, June 22 — Dip your toes into tabletop roleplaying games with Free RPG Day, celebrated at Good Games in downtown Indy and other local game stores near you.

Eiteljorg Indian Market & Festival, June 22-23 — Spend a summer day enjoying handcrafted art, food and music from 140+ indigenous artists.

The post The Monthly Mullet, June 2024 appeared first on Kicks Digital Marketing.

Okay, so the name Kicks “Digital” Marketing isn’t entirely accurate. Did you know that we make kick-ass print marketing collateral, too?

Brochures, trade show banners, business cards — you name it, we write it, design it, and help you get it printed. More like Kicks “Physical” Marketing, amirite?

A bold reimagining of the Indy 500

Here in Indy, we love to watch cars turn left. But what if… just for once, they turned to the right instead? Here’s what the twisted minds at Kicks think it could look like.

Kickin’ It Around Indy

I Made Rock ‘N’ Roll, May 18 — Headlined by Janelle Monáe, this one-day Black rock festival at the American Legion Mall is sponsored by local movers and shakers Forty5 and GANGGANG.

Indy 500, May 26 — If you don’t know what this is, kindly turn in your Hoosier ID card and am-scray.

The post The Monthly Mullet, May 2024 appeared first on Kicks Digital Marketing.

You know those “do not remove under penalty of law” tags that are on pillows and beds and whatnot? Turns out the world of compliance for stuffed articles is serious business — and nobody is more serious about getting it right than Global Registration Services.

GRS is the undisputed king of compliance in their industry, but their website was undisputedly in need of some lovin’. Kicks streamlined their highly technical content into something much more digestible — and we gave it a much-needed makeover, too.

Check out our latest case study to see how Kicks put some OMG into GRS’s new website.

Rockin’ Around the Kicksmas Tree

We beat the naughty child allegations, and we officially made Santa’s nice list. Here’s what we’re hoping to find under the Kicksmas tree this year.

Matt — I need a new outdoor grill. When I moved into my house a couple of years ago I didn’t have a grill and I just never ended up getting one. I have a small backyard that’s hard to get to so I want to get a smaller grill that can fit on my front porch without burning the house down.

Josh — My shopping habits and desire for instant gratification creates a problem for the Christmas season. What I want this year is a wonderful Christmas where people don’t overstay their welcome at my house. 

Chris — I think I’m ready for my first Kindle. Not because I read a ton, but because when I’m reading I get super cozy and the idea of reaching out from under my blanket to flip the page of a real book feels like the biggest challenge in the world.

Summer — Ya girl really needs to stop fooling around in the kitchen and finally get a Kitchenaid mixer. Why am I using baking as a replacement for arm day?? What a workout. I need a mixer pronto.

Kickin’ It Around Indy

Christkindlmarkt at The Athenaeum, through Dec 17 — Downtown is dressing up for the season, with The Athenaeum’s annual Christmas market. Eat, drink and be merry with tons of vendors and wintertime fun to be had.

Christkindlmarkt in Carmel, through Dec 24 — For the north-inclined, Carmel will once again hold their own Christmas market featuring seasonal food, drink, and tidings of comfort and joy.

Winterlights at Newfields, through Jan 8 — Oh, you like holiday lights? Then name every million and a half of them that will be strung around the garden behind Newfields. We’ll wait.

The post The Monthly Mullet, December 2023 appeared first on Kicks Digital Marketing.

What do you do when you’ve got a super talented team, but no name, branding or website? You do what the legal and financial experts at the now-named Torchlight Resolutions do — put Kicks on the case.

Oddball Gobbles

Thanksgiving is a time of tradition, but what if we, like, didn’t? Here’s how the Kicks crew remixes the standard T-Gives tradish.

Matt — My family is very traditional for Thanksgiving. My dad is an excellent cook so every part of the meal is super tasty. We save the meal experimenting for other holidays.

Josh — I go full-ass into the holiday cooking. I will be the one moving with the grace and precision of a peregrine falcon. The kicker? I do all holiday meals with caloric density in mind so that we can enjoy more than seven minutes at the table. 

Chris — Thanksgiving food can be super bland, so my family usually tosses some Indian-inspired dishes in the mix to kick the spice factor up a notch. Pass the pav bhaji, please.

Summer — Pretty traditional over here! Plenty of turkey (sometimes smoked!), a kiddie-pool filled with mashed potatoes, and 1 singular can of cranberry sauce to stretch across 15 people.

Kickin’ It Around Indy

Fear is the mind killer, Nov 3 — Nerds rise up, it’s opening day for Dune: Chapter Two! If you’ve somehow managed to avoid spoilers for a 58-year-old book, you’re in for a wild ride.

Election Day, Nov 7 — Go vote, ya schmucks.

WinterFaire, opens Nov 18 — Move over Jolly Days, the Children’s Museum is starting a new tradition. Catch the Kicks crew spelunking in WinterFaire’s indoor ice cave.

Don’t talk to me until I’ve had my international coffee, Nov 18 — You can do better than the cup of mud from your office’s Keurig. Expand your palate at the 4th annual International Coffee & Tea Fest.

The post The Monthly Mullet, November 2023 appeared first on Kicks Digital Marketing.

Indy is home to some killer videography talent, if you know where to look. To help get more eyes on their work and land more business, Mork Productions tapped Kicks to pump up their website with some SEO prowess and slick design.

See how we got the job done and got Mork Productions the awareness they deserve in our latest case study.

Halloweiners

Halloween is for the kids, and as kids at heart the Kicks crew loves us some costumes and free candy. Here are some of our Halloween highlights throughout the years.

Matt — I’ve never been a big costume guy, but I appreciate the effort some other people make. The craftsmanship down in Bloomington when I was at IU was unbelievable. Kids that probably should have been in class and not at Goodwill piecing together the perfect ensemble. 

Josh — When I was a handsome baby boy, I wanted to go as a football player and go out with the neighborhood kids trick-or-treating. My mom gave me shoulder pads from her old 80s jackets and put makeup on my face. At the time, I thought everyone knew and it would be lame. I cried. I didn’t go out. I now hate halloween. 

Chris — Back in college I made a 3D Pac-Man costume and had my friends wear shirts of the ghosts. I chased them through unsuspecting classrooms and around campus for a couple hours. 

Summer — In high school I had a momentary obsession with Sally from the Nightmare Before Christmas (she’s so relatable, what of it??) and I sewed an entire patchwork dress for Halloween and did my own stitched mouth makeup. It was a whole vibe.

Kickin’ It Around Indy

Cuuuuuuuuuuute — This month the zoo is anticipating the birth of a baby elephant! There’s some portmanteau of “elephant” and “infant” we could use here, but we’ll let you do the heavy lifting.

My spider sense is tingling, Oct 3 — If you like spiders and men, then you’ll love Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse with live musicians at Clowes Hall. Grab your tickets right here. 

Heartland Intl. Film Festival, Oct 5-15 — 300+ independent films across Indy’s artsiest venues. If you’re a movie buff, you’d be a philistine not to snag your tickets.

The post The Monthly Mullet, October 2023 appeared first on Kicks Digital Marketing.

This one’s major, folks: not only are we card-carrying members of the Indy Chamber, we were also honored to rebuild their massive, all-encompassing website for all things good and local.

Events calendars, membership enrollment, resource libraries — we break it all down in our latest case study.

Labor Day? More like LAme/BORing DAY jobs.

Think about the worst job you ever had. Now wash it away with a shot of whisky and listen in as Kicks reminisces about our crappiest 9-5’s.

Matt — Fortunately, I haven’t had a terrible 9-5 job. Parts of my past jobs have been pretty bad, though. My first job was cleaning movie theaters after the shows. Next I was a lifeguard, but part of our duties were cleaning the bathrooms every day after the pool closed. Both jobs made me appreciate people that clean up after themselves.

Josh — Angie’s List. Nuff said. (it turns hopeful college grads into money hungry monsters with little to no security)

Chris — When I was freelancing, I had a “boss” who would literally breathe down people’s necks while they worked. Nothing gets me more in the mood to write blogs than getting flavor-blasted by chicken salad sandwich breath.

Summer — I’d say the worst kind of job you can have is one that eventually crushes your spirit. Fresh out of college, bright-eyed, hopeful…a few years later, an agency had wrung it out of me. My advice? Don’t stay too long if your concerns are continually ignored.

Kickin’ It Around Indy

Oktoberfest? Jawohl! — Did you know that Oktoberfest is actually the celebration leading up to the titular month? That means September is prime time to drink lots of good ol’ local lagers at your brewery of choice.

Penrod Arts Fair, Sep 9 — Let’s get artsy fartsy! Penrod is back for their 56th year at Newfields, where you’ll find tons of artists, food and drink to keep you busy on the self-proclaimed “Indiana’s Nicest Day.”

ALL IN Music & Arts Festival, Sep 9-10 — Listen, there are probably a ton of talented bands playing here but TENACIOUS FRIGGING D is enough to make this festival worth the cost of admission.

The post The Monthly Mullet, September 2023 appeared first on Kicks Digital Marketing.